Monday, December 8, 2008

Investment Banking - Mergers and Acquisitions (M&A)

Merging with, or acquiring, a business is one way of increasing business value for a company.

It can include the following:

  • Acquisitions - buying a company by acquiring some or all of its stock or assets
  • Divestitures - splitting up and/or selling off existing parts of a business
  • Mergers – buying a company through a legal arrangement whereby all shareholders of the acquired company receive stock or cash
  • Strategic alliances - working closely with other companies to pursue a mutual advantage
  • Joint ventures - forming a new company with other parties. However, unlike a merger, this new company is a separate entity, with the parent companies still retaining their original identities
When increasing competitive pressures are placed on businesses and with the trend to globalization, companies engage in M&A activity.

Many companies looking to expand, or streamline, their business will use investment banks for advice on potential targets and/or buyers. This will normally include a full valuation and recommended tactics. Each party to a transaction will have their own M&A advisor.

Such advice is particularly necessary for M&A deals that involve uniting companies from different countries. These types of deals, that involve more than one country, are known as cross border deals. As you can imagine, cross border deals often involve working with different countries' accounting, tax and company laws. These types of deals can then become extremely complex.

Many large international companies have, therefore, set up internal M&A teams. These teams have developed substantial experience in planning and executing deals and tend to carry out the search for potential targets and threats themselves. However, these companies are still open to investment banks bringing forward potential deals and will still generally need an investment bank to advise on valuations and tactics / negotiations.

In an ideal world M&Atransactions would simply involve the matching of a seller and a buyer, or in the case of a merger, the bringing together of two interested parties. However, this is not always the case and sometimes one company will be threatened by another. In these types of deals one company will try and buy or merge with another without that company's consent. This is better known as a hostile takeover.

M&A transactions can occur through an acquisition of stock, an acquisition of assets or a merger. A merger is a legal arrangement whereby all shareholders of the acquired company automatically receive stock in the acquiring company as consideration in return for their stock in the acquired company. A merger often requires a shareholder vote and board approval.

The Investment bank's role, in both these types of deals, falls into one of either two buckets: seller representation or buyer representation (also called target representation and acquirer representation).

For an investment bank, M&Aadvising is highly profitable, and the possibilities of types of transactions are virtually unlimited. Perhaps a small private company's owner/manager wishes to sell out for cash and retire. Or perhaps a big public firm aims to buy a competitor through a stock swap.

Also, remember that investment banks do not just rely on buyers and sellers approaching them, they will also study the market themselves and have been known to approach companies with their own strategic ideas (i.e. they might suggest that two companies merge, or that one company acquires, or sells, to another).

Let us look in more detail at the role of the investment bank in representing either the seller or the buyer.

An investment bank that represents a potential seller has a much greater likelihood of completing a transaction (and therefore being paid) than an investment bank that represents a potential acquirer.

This seller representation, also known as sell-side work, is the type of advisory assignment that is generated by a company when it approaches an investment bank and asks it to find a buyer of either the entire company or part of its assets.

Generally speaking, the work involved in finding a buyer includes writing a "Selling Memorandum" (a detailed sales document) and then contacting potential strategic or financial buyers.

If the client hopes to sell a high tech factory, for instance, then the investment bank will contact firms in the same industry, as well as "buyout" firms that focus on purchasing technology or high-tech manufacturing operations.

In advising sellers, the investment bank's work is complete once another party purchases the business up for sale (i.e. once another party buys the client's company or assets).

However, representing a buyer is not always as straight forward.

The advisory work itself is simple enough: the investment bank contacts the firm their client wishes to purchase, attempts to structure an acceptable offer for all parties, and make the deal a reality.

However, many of these proposals do not work out; few firms or owners are willing to readily sell their business. Because the investment banks primarily collect fees based on completed transactions, their work often goes unpaid.

Consequently, when advising clients looking to buy a business, an investment bank's work often drags on for months.

In many cases a firm will, therefore, pay a non-refundable retainer fee to hire an investment bank and say, "find us a target company to buy." These acquisition searches can also last for months and produce nothing except associate and analyst fatigue as they repeatedly build merger models and work through the night.

However, these types of deals are still very attractive to investment banks because when the deals do "get done" the fees that are generated can be enormous.

Investment Banking - Capital Structuring

Capital Structuring is, simply put, how a company chooses to arrange its finances in terms of income, expenses, assets and debts.

How a company chooses to structure its capital is not dissimilar to how someone structures their personal finances.

On a daily basis people have to make decisions with regard to how they choose to spend their money and a company’s management is no different.

Some people may take a long-term view with their finances and save for a point in the future while others may decide to take the short-term view and enjoy themselves in the present. Of course both views have their own rewards and consequences.

Likewise, a company may choose to make maximum short-term profits (a fast buck) or invest for middle and long-term gain.

Of course on both a personal and business level, spending money in itself is not necessarily bad, rather it is what you spend your money on that counts.

Let’s take some personal examples.

There is a big difference, in terms of capital structuring, between spending money on a holiday and a car (besides the obvious material ones).

The holiday has a very limited value in that when the holiday is over you cannot get back any of the money that you spent on it.

A car, on the other hand, is an asset because, depending on general wear and tear, it has some re-sale value. A re-sale value that could at some point in the future be utilized.

Another good example would be the use of a mortgage to help purchase a home.

As the years go by the actual outstanding debt decreases, the owner holds more equity value in the house and eventually the owner will own the property outright.

Because both the car and the property purchases have an asset-based component to them, the type of borrowing offered is normally cheaper than non-asset based lending.

A mortgage-lending rate, for instance, may be a quarter of that charged by a credit card company.

The reason for this difference is simple – with asset based lending the risk to the lender is reduced because if the person owing the debt cannot meet the repayments then the assets that the loan was used to purchase can simply be resold and all or part of the debt repaid.

For the managers of a business the same choices apply when deciding how to spend the company’s money and how to finance those purchases.

The role of Capital Structuring is simply to get the right balance between equity (its own money) and debt (borrowed money).

Getting the right balance between what a company owns and how it uses those assets to fund itself is a complex task.

An investment bank can constantly review a company’s capital structure, assessing the requirements for change based on the company’s latest business outlook, investment requirements and financial market conditions.

This review is not just limited to raising funds for investment and expansion. It can also be done to ensure that a company is being as efficient as possible in managing its debt.

Let us use another personal example. If a person who has many debts (i.e. credit cards, store cards and personal loans) each with its own repayment amount then it can be cheaper to take out one new loan, with an asset or assets as security (i.e. property).

This new loan can then pay off all the other debts. Its repayment amount will be substantially less because unlike the other loans this new one is secured. The money saved, by having this lower repayment, can then be used to purchase something else or save.

An investment bank can offer similar advice to a company and thus can change the existing balance between equity and debt. This process is known as restructuring.

When it comes to funding an investment or expansion as a company then there will always be a choice between risk and expected return.

The modeling work done by an investment bank during valuation can help to map out what the risks and the expected returns might be and hence allow a company’s management to make fully informed decisions.

This work may also help convince potential lenders that this is a low risk venture (i.e. investors are likely to get their original money back with profits).

Just as with personal lending, the amount of risk attached to the lender will determine to a large extent the amount charged for the raising of funds.

As you can imagine, there is a vast amount of ways in which a company can raise funds, or restructure its debt, and the investment bank can use its expertise here to help the firm choose a path that maximizes its shareholder value.

The level of risk attached to lending money to a business in order for that business to expand or grow can be placed on the following spectrum:

► At one end of the spectrum are the expansion plans in which all the money lent will be used to purchase assets. A good example is the purchase of a new vehicle that will be used in the core business of the company. These types of projects are good candidates for low-cost financing
► Asset-backed loans, usually from one lender, are the most common type of lending for this type of expansion
► At the other end of this spectrum are projects in which a substantial portion of the money
lent is to be used to fund soft costs (i.e. they do not involve the purchase of assets – research and development being a common example). Because this type of expansion generates little in the way of assets, in the short term, it is more difficult to secure a traditional (secured) loan
The company may, therefore, issue securities (stocks and bonds) to fund this action.
Somewhere in the middle of this spectrum lie those situations in which the asset values are too low to secure asset-backed financing for the entire transaction, but in which the historic performance of the business is such, or the likelihood that the expansion effort will succeed are so great, that a senior lender will make what is termed a cash flow loan.

With a cash flow loan the lender holds his or her, metaphorical, breath for the period of the time that the loan is outstanding, hoping that the loan repayments hold up and the loan itself is repaid.
As you can imagine, cash flow loans are always more expensive than asset-backed, or secured, loans and are generally only available from larger, more sophisticated banks and financial institutions.

Investment Banking - Valuation

Given that the management of a company is tasked with the maximization of shareholder value, it follows then that the biggest challenge for any company management is to come up with the ideas and recommendations that allow this maximization to occur.

Even the most successful management teams cannot afford to be complacent. In today’s ever-changing world, nothing remains the same for long, especially a business advantage.

The old saying “if its not broken then don’t fix it” has been replaced with “if you are standing still, then you are already behind the competition”.

The challenge then for a company’s management is to both constantly review where they have been (i.e., what has been successful and what needs to change) and where they are going (i.e. what will the marketplace, the competition, the technology and a host of other variables be like in the short and long term future).

Maximum shareholder value is thus achieved through strategic and sound financial management decisions. These decisions are most successful when based upon past performance and future plans.

This process can be enhanced by following the advice of an investment bank which will assess the value of the company (the past) and proposed projects (the future).

Investment banks are experts at calculating what a business is worth.
They are also able to predict how that worth could be altered (i.e. what happens to the value of a company in a number of different scenarios and what those potential futures would mean financially).

This is invaluable to a management team that is considering one of several future plans.
It is much easier to make the right decision (to maximize shareholder value) once it is known what the likely outcomes will be (i.e. what that transaction will add to future shareholder value).

This valuation ability is generally used for the following purposes:

► To price a securities offering (i.e. what is the likely price and best time to sell company stocks and bonds)
► To measure the impact of any restructuring (i.e. selling off or down sizing existing business areas) or investment plans
► To set the value of a merger or acquisition (i.e. how much it would cost to “buy” a company)

Financial models* are constructed by investment banks to capture the most important fixed and variable financial components that could influence the overall value of a company.
These models, depending upon the proposed transaction, can be extremely complex with special variables being added for special areas (i.e. there are different financial factors to consider in different sectors, countries and markets when predicting or measuring a company’s value).